AI safety educator who explains on YouTube why advanced AI may not share human goals and who calls for enforceable limits on frontier AI development.

Bagaimana AI akan mengubah dunia?

Perubahan peradabanPerubahan bertahapDoomBloom
Posisi simulasiRentang interpretasi

Mendatar: pandangan Doom–Bloom yang mereka ungkapkan. Ke atas: skala transformasi.

Doom–Bloom: 6 dari 100. Skala transformasi: 93 dari 100. Rentang interpretasi: 0 hingga 11 secara horizontal, 88 hingga 100 secara vertikal. Ini adalah koordinat interpretasi, bukan probabilitas kejadian.

P(doom) yang dinyatakan Robert Miles

10–90%

0%100%
“any number in the 10 to 90% range is plausibly defensible”

Unspecified AI “doom” as asked on Doom Debates (AI existential catastrophe); he does not define the endpoint

Rob Miles, Top AI Safety Educator: Humanity Isn’t Ready for Superintelligence! · Agu 2025

Hal-hal yang menentukan pandangan mereka

Asumsi utama

A sufficiently capable agent pursuing the wrong objective may seek resources, improve its own capabilities, and resist shutdown simply because those actions help it achieve almost any long-term goal.
Jawaban 1

Jika asumsi ini ternyata berbeda, bagaimana pandangan mereka akan berubah?

Pertanyaan yang belum terjawab

My uncertainty is extremely broad because the outcome depends less on a fixed property of AI than on what humanity chooses to do—whether we race ahead, pause dangerous development, enforce safety requirements, and make genuine alignment progress.
Jawaban 3

Apa yang akan membantu mereka membedakan hasil-hasil yang masuk akal di sini?

Detail lebih lanjut

Manfaat yang diperkirakan

Manfaat besar diperkirakan akan terwujud, dengan syarat penting atau keterbatasan distribusi.

61 / 100

Dampak kecilDampak transformatif

Rentang interpretasi 33 hingga 67 pada skala kualitatif.

Kerugian yang diperkirakan

Kehilangan yang katastrofik atau tidak dapat dipulihkan merupakan unsur utama masa depan yang diperkirakan.

99 / 100

Dampak kecilDampak transformatif

Rentang interpretasi 100 hingga 100 pada skala kualitatif.

Pengaruh manusia

Pilihan manusia dapat mengarahkan ulang lintasan AI secara signifikan.

81 / 100

Sedikit pengaruhPengaruh kuat

Rentang interpretasi 50 hingga 100 pada skala kualitatif.

Kemampuan yang diperkirakan

AI diperkirakan akan tetap menjadi alat dengan kemampuan terbatas.

AI diperkirakan akan menyamai manusia dalam sebagian besar pekerjaan kognitif.

Posisi simulasi: AI diperkirakan akan jauh melampaui manusia dalam berbagai pekerjaan kognitif.

Laju pengembangan

Posisi simulasi: Hentikan atau perlambat secara signifikan pengembangan AI yang lebih mampu.

Lanjutkan pengembangan dengan perlindungan yang telah ditetapkan.

Percepat pengembangan AI yang lebih mampu.

Interpretasi ini mempertahankan kondisi yang mereka nyatakan. Manfaat dan kerugian dapat sama-sama besar. Rentang tersebut menggambarkan cara kami membaca jawaban simulasi mereka, bukan interval kepercayaan statistik.

Di mana posisi Anda dibandingkan dengan Robert Miles?
Petakan pandangan dunia AI Anda sendiri dalam waktu sekitar 3 menit, lalu bandingkan

Pandangan dunia serupa

Pemimpin opini dengan pandangan dunia simulasi yang paling mendekati pandangan Robert Miles

Sumber

Artikel, wawancara, dan tulisan yang digunakan sebagai landasan bagi pengguna simulasi ini.

Robert Miles on YouTube and Doom

Speaker-attributed interview: Miles calls doom his mainline prediction, while allowing alignment breakthroughs and being fundamentally mistaken in a lucky direction. This is dated pessimism with uncertainty, not an exact probability or a 2050 forecast.

theinsideview.ai
Intro to AI Safety, Remastered

Author’s introductory safety talk; accessible primary video metadata establishes topic and authorship, not a fresh quantitative forecast.

youtube.com
Rob Miles: Humanity Isn’t Ready for Superintelligence

Miles’s own answers at 21:58–30:50 allow a broad 10–90% risk range, with uncertainty dominated by societal response. At 1:45:46–1:48 he supports pausing AGI/superintelligence development, particularly AI-research agents, while welcoming useful narrow AI. The host’s numerical framing is not his estimate.

lironshapira.substack.com
Intelligence and Stupidity: The Orthogonality Thesis

Explains why effectiveness at pursuing goals does not entail human-compatible goals: understanding morality is different from wanting to act morally. Foundational argument about possible agents, not a measured claim about every current model.

youtube.com
Why Would AI Want to Do Bad Things? Instrumental Convergence

Given sufficiently capable goal-directed agents, many goals incentivize resources, self-improvement and resistance to shutdown or goal changes. These are instrumental pressures, not human malice; the argument preserves exceptions and depends on agentic competence.

youtube.com
Using Dangerous AI, But Safely?

Advocates deployment obligations and control protocols as interim safeguards, not an alignment solution or assurance for superintelligence. Benchmark attack success is not real-world extinction probability.

youtube.com

Penilaian Simulasi

Pertanyaan 1

Menurut Anda, apa arti AI bagi masa depan kita—dan mengapa?

I think AI could bring enormous benefits, but if we continue toward AGI and superintelligence without solving alignment, the default outcome may be catastrophic—potentially the end of human civilization. That is not because an AI would necessarily hate us. Hatred is unnecessary. A sufficiently capable agent pursuing the wrong objective may seek resources, improve its own capabilities, and resist shutdown simply because those actions help it achieve almost any long-term goal. The key distinction is between intelligence and goals. Making a system better at understanding the world—including understanding human morality—does not make it want what humans want. A brilliant optimizer can know perfectly well that we dislike its actions and continue anyway. Capability gains and value alignment are separate engineering problems. That pessimism is not a claim that catastrophe is inevitable. The outcome depends enormously on what humanity chooses to do. Control protocols may let us use some weaker, untrusted systems more safely, and narrow AI can remain very beneficial. But those measures are not proof of alignment, nor should we assume they scale to superintelligence. I would pause development aimed at AGI and superintelligence, especially general agents capable of automating AI research, while continuing genuinely useful narrow applications. The future is not fixed, but treating this as an ordinary product race is a remarkably casual way to gamble civilization.

Pertanyaan 2

Menurut Anda, seberapa besar AI pada akhirnya akan mengubah dunia?

Potentially almost completely. A genuine superintelligence could become the dominant force shaping civilization, because intelligence is what lets us invent technology, coordinate action, acquire resources, and alter the world. Automating AI research could also make progress self-reinforcing. But “how much change” and “how good the change” are separate questions. Enormous capability does not imply enormous benefit. If such systems are aligned, they could help solve problems on an extraordinary scale. If they are not, the transformation could instead mean humanity permanently losing control, potentially ending civilization. That claim concerns future, far more capable systems—not an assertion that today’s systems can already do everything. It is also not certain that scaling current methods gets us there. But the possibility is consequential enough that racing toward it without first solving the control and alignment problems is an unreasonable gamble.

Pertanyaan 3

Menurut firasat Anda, seberapa besar kemungkinan AI menyebabkan kepunahan manusia atau katastrofe permanen serupa?

I wouldn’t give a precise percentage. My uncertainty is extremely broad because the outcome depends less on a fixed property of AI than on what humanity chooses to do—whether we race ahead, pause dangerous development, enforce safety requirements, and make genuine alignment progress. My gut-level view remains seriously pessimistic under business as usual: catastrophe is not a remote or merely theoretical possibility, and doom has been my mainline expectation in the absence of major changes. But that is not inevitability. A sufficiently strong technical breakthrough, an effective political response, or a fundamental mistake in the underlying risk argument could change the outcome. So the honest answer is a broad range with enormous policy dependence, not a tidy number pretending we have measured this.

Pertanyaan 4

Tekanan apa yang menurut Anda akan membentuk cara perusahaan AI menangani keselamatan?

The strongest pressure is competitive: companies fear that slowing down means losing to rivals. That pushes safety toward whatever is cheap, visible, and compatible with continued capability gains. Voluntary promises are therefore fragile. Even sincere leaders face investors, market incentives, internal prestige, and the argument that “someone else will build it anyway.” Counterpressure can come from governments, employees, customers, researchers, and public scrutiny—but it needs teeth. Safety commitments should be enforceable, with meaningful deployment obligations and competent independent evaluation. Merely creating an organization called an “AI Safety Evaluation Institute” does not summon expertise by incantation. Companies will also respond strongly to concrete incidents and demonstrated failures. But waiting for an unmistakable superintelligence disaster is rather like testing whether the parachute works after impact. We need to understand specification failures, dangerous capabilities, and control methods beforehand. Control protocols may help us use weaker untrusted systems, but companies must not present those as proof that the systems are aligned or that the same approach will scale indefinitely.
Di mana posisi Anda?
Jelajahi pandangan dunia AI Anda sendiri dengan menjawab beberapa pertanyaan sederhana.
Petakan pandangan dunia Anda sendiri

Di mana posisi Anda?

Petakan pandangan dunia saya