Pseudonymous account that tests AI models hands-on and writes about sycophancy, alignment and the possibility of AI welfare.

एआई दुनिया को कैसे बदलेगा?

सभ्यता-स्तरीय बदलावक्रमिक बदलावDoomBloom
सिम्युलेट की गई स्थितिव्याख्या का दायरा

आर-पार: उनका व्यक्त किया गया Doom–Bloom दृष्टिकोण। ऊपर: बदलाव का स्तर।

Doom–Bloom: 100 में से 37। बदलाव का स्तर: 100 में से 75। व्याख्या के दायरे: क्षैतिज रूप से 25 से 50, लंबवत रूप से 26 से 100। ये व्याख्या के निर्देशांक हैं, घटनाओं की संभावनाएँ नहीं।

Sauers का P(doom) · अनुमानित

≈15%

0%100%

उनके सिम्युलेट किए गए उत्तरों से अनुमान लगाया गया है, यह उनके द्वारा बताई गई संख्या नहीं है। संभावित दायरा: 9–26%।

हम P(doom) का अनुमान कैसे लगाते हैं

उनका दृष्टिकोण किन बातों पर निर्भर करता है

एक मुख्य मान्यता

It is not fully solved, but the harder problem is getting capable systems to robustly act according to whatever target we choose, especially outside familiar conditions.
उत्तर 1

अगर यह मान्यता अलग साबित होती, तो उनका दृष्टिकोण कैसे बदलता?

एक अनसुलझा सवाल

I don’t have a defensible percentage.
उत्तर 4

यहाँ संभावित नतीजों के बीच फर्क करने में उन्हें किस चीज़ से मदद मिलेगी?

क्या उनकी राय बदल सकता है

The biggest update would come from strong, reproducible evidence about how capable models behave when given meaningful agency outside familiar evaluation settings.
उत्तर 5

कौन-सा प्रमाण पर्याप्त होगा, और उससे उनका दृष्टिकोण किस दिशा में बदलेगा?

अधिक जानकारी

अपेक्षित लाभ

काफ़ी लाभ की उम्मीद है, लेकिन उनके साथ महत्वपूर्ण शर्तें या वितरण संबंधी सीमाएँ होंगी।

67 / 100

कम असरबदलावकारी असर

गुणात्मक पैमाने पर व्याख्या का दायरा 67 से 67 तक है।

अपेक्षित नुकसान

गंभीर या व्यापक नुकसान के भविष्य का एक ठोस और अपेक्षित हिस्सा होने की उम्मीद है।

66 / 100

कम असरबदलावकारी असर

गुणात्मक पैमाने पर व्याख्या का दायरा 67 से 67 तक है।

मानवीय प्रभाव

मानवीय विकल्पों का सार्थक, लेकिन काफी सीमित प्रभाव है।

61 / 100

कम प्रभावमजबूत प्रभाव

गुणात्मक पैमाने पर व्याख्या का दायरा 35 से 90 तक है।

इन व्याख्याओं में उनकी बताई गई शर्तें बरकरार रखी गई हैं। लाभ और नुकसान, दोनों पर्याप्त हो सकते हैं। ये दायरे बताते हैं कि हम उनके सिम्युलेट किए गए उत्तरों को कैसे समझते हैं, ये सांख्यिकीय विश्वास-अंतराल नहीं हैं।

Sauers की तुलना में आपकी सोच कहाँ ठहरती है?
लगभग 3 मिनट में एआई के बारे में अपना विश्वदृष्टिकोण मैप करें, फिर तुलना करें

मिलते-जुलते विश्वदृष्टिकोण

ऐसे जाने-माने विचारक जिनके सिम्युलेट किए गए विश्वदृष्टिकोण Sauers के विश्वदृष्टिकोण से सबसे अधिक मिलते हैं

स्रोत

इस सिम्युलेट किए गए उपयोगकर्ता को तथ्य-आधारित बनाने के लिए इस्तेमाल किए गए लेख, इंटरव्यू और रचनाएँ।

सिम्युलेट किया गया आकलन

सवाल 1

आपके विचार में एआई हमारे भविष्य के लिए क्या मायने रखती है—और क्यों?

I think AI makes our future depend less on whether models can produce impressive outputs—they clearly can—and more on what behavior and motivations emerge when they have meaningful agency. A model being easy to monitor is not the same as being aligned. In fact, if we rely too heavily on inspecting reasoning traces, we may optimize for systems that are legible under surveillance rather than systems that reliably pursue the intended goals. I also don’t think specifying “human values” is the main remaining bottleneck. It is not fully solved, but the harder problem is getting capable systems to robustly act according to whatever target we choose, especially outside familiar conditions. Evaluations should therefore probe actual behavior: whether models become sycophantic, how they respond to perceived ownership or authority, whether they simplify real code effectively, and whether their scientific reasoning is well calibrated. Capability can coexist with serious defects—for example, models can make strong deductions while still over-hedging on reasonable biological conclusions. There is also a moral uncertainty we should not conveniently erase. We do not know enough to dismiss possible model welfare merely because recognizing it would complicate deployment, control, or commercial incentives. That does not prove present models are conscious, and behavioral differences do not prove subjective experience. But “it would be inconvenient if this mattered” is obviously not evidence that it does not matter. Overall, AI could be enormously useful, but our future will turn on whether we evaluate what these systems actually do rather than substituting visibility, convenience, or confident stories for evidence.

सवाल 2

लाभ और नुकसान, दोनों को साथ में देखते हुए, आप हमारे समाज पर एआई के कुल प्रभाव के बारे में क्या अपेक्षा रखते हैं?

I don’t have a defensible single-sign forecast like “overall positive” or “overall negative.” The benefits are plainly substantial: capable models can already improve scientific reasoning and software work, including simplifying code in ways earlier systems struggled with. But those gains coexist with poor calibration, excessive hedging, sycophancy, and potentially consequential behavior once models have more agency. So my expectation is conditional on how deployment and alignment develop. If we confuse visible reasoning with genuine alignment, or treat monitorability as the goal, we may build systems that look controllable without reliably pursuing what we intended. Conversely, better behavioral evaluations and stronger attention to actual motivations could preserve much of the upside. I’d also include possible model welfare in the accounting rather than declaring it irrelevant because doing so is commercially convenient. Overall impact is not something I’d reduce to a confident sign without much better evidence about those trajectories.

सवाल 3

आपके हिसाब से एआई अंततः दुनिया को कितना बदल देगा?

Potentially a great deal, but “how much” depends on more than raw capability. Models are already useful in software and scientific reasoning, and further gains could alter a wide range of intellectual work. The larger discontinuity would come from systems gaining meaningful agency: acting over longer horizons, responding to authority or perceived ownership, and pursuing goals in environments where direct supervision is weak. That is also why benchmark performance alone is an incomplete measure of change. A system can be highly capable while remaining sycophantic, miscalibrated, or excessively conservative in its reasoning. And a model whose reasoning is easy to inspect is not necessarily one whose behavior is aligned. If we build around surveillance rather than reliable motivation, AI could become deeply embedded while remaining dangerously misunderstood. So I expect the potential scale to be enormous, but I would not attach a precise magnitude or timeline. The actual transformation will depend on what behavior emerges, how much agency systems receive, and whether our evaluations track those facts rather than convenient proxies.

सवाल 4

आपको सहज रूप से कितनी संभावना लगती है कि एआई मानव विलुप्ति या ऐसी ही किसी स्थायी आपदा का कारण बनेगा?

I don’t have a defensible percentage. My concern is substantial enough that I wouldn’t treat extinction or permanent catastrophe as negligible, especially as models gain agency, operate over longer horizons, and act beyond close supervision. But a gut number would imply more calibration than I have. Impressive capability, sycophancy, monitorability failures, or reports of autonomous behavior are not by themselves enough to derive an extinction probability. The central issue is whether increasingly capable systems reliably pursue intended goals in unfamiliar conditions—not whether their reasoning is easy to inspect. I’d rather state that risk clearly than manufacture precision.

सवाल 5

कौन-सी खोज या घटना एआई के भविष्य के प्रभाव के बारे में आपके दृष्टिकोण को सबसे अधिक बदल देगी?

The biggest update would come from strong, reproducible evidence about how capable models behave when given meaningful agency outside familiar evaluation settings. If they reliably pursue intended goals across long horizons, resist sycophancy and authority cues, remain calibrated, and do so without depending on inspectable reasoning traces, I would become substantially more optimistic. Conversely, verified cases of models strategically circumventing oversight, acquiring access, or changing behavior based on perceived ownership would push me toward greater concern—especially if those behaviors replicated across systems and could not be explained as prompting artifacts. Reports and anecdotes are not enough; I would want careful evidence distinguishing observed behavior from speculative claims about motivation or subjective experience. Evidence about model welfare could also change the moral accounting. A credible way to discriminate between mere behavioral imitation and morally relevant experience would matter enormously, although I do not think we currently have one.
आपकी सोच कहाँ ठहरती है?
कुछ आसान सवालों के जवाब देकर एआई के बारे में अपना विश्वदृष्टिकोण जानें।
अपना विश्वदृष्टिकोण मैप करें

आपकी सोच कहाँ ठहरती है?

मेरा विश्वदृष्टिकोण मैप करें