Programmer who is enthusiastic about practical AI and argues that ordinary people should own it rather than depend on a few companies or governments.

एआई दुनिया को कैसे बदलेगा?

सभ्यता-स्तरीय बदलावक्रमिक बदलावDoomBloom
सिम्युलेट की गई स्थितिव्याख्या का दायरा

आर-पार: उनका व्यक्त किया गया Doom–Bloom दृष्टिकोण। ऊपर: बदलाव का स्तर।

Doom–Bloom: 100 में से 68। बदलाव का स्तर: 100 में से 69। व्याख्या के दायरे: क्षैतिज रूप से 63 से 75, लंबवत रूप से 64 से 75। ये व्याख्या के निर्देशांक हैं, घटनाओं की संभावनाएँ नहीं।

George Hotz का P(doom) · अनुमानित

≈6%

0%100%

उनके सिम्युलेट किए गए उत्तरों से अनुमान लगाया गया है, यह उनके द्वारा बताई गई संख्या नहीं है। संभावित दायरा: 3–9%।

हम P(doom) का अनुमान कैसे लगाते हैं

उनका दृष्टिकोण किन बातों पर निर्भर करता है

एक मुख्य मान्यता

Compute is distributed, competitors copy useful ideas, and real-world agents still face search, coordination, and judgment problems.
उत्तर 1

अगर यह मान्यता अलग साबित होती, तो उनका दृष्टिकोण कैसे बदलता?

अधिक जानकारी

अपेक्षित लाभ

काफ़ी लाभ की उम्मीद है, लेकिन उनके साथ महत्वपूर्ण शर्तें या वितरण संबंधी सीमाएँ होंगी।

77 / 100

कम असरबदलावकारी असर

गुणात्मक पैमाने पर व्याख्या का दायरा 67 से 100 तक है।

अपेक्षित नुकसान

गंभीर या व्यापक नुकसान के भविष्य का एक ठोस और अपेक्षित हिस्सा होने की उम्मीद है।

60 / 100

कम असरबदलावकारी असर

गुणात्मक पैमाने पर व्याख्या का दायरा 33 से 67 तक है।

मानवीय प्रभाव

मानवीय विकल्प एआई की दिशा को काफी हद तक बदल सकते हैं।

67 / 100

कम प्रभावमजबूत प्रभाव

गुणात्मक पैमाने पर व्याख्या का दायरा 49 से 100 तक है।

एआई तक पहुँच

शक्तिशाली एआई तक पहुँच प्रतिबंधित करें।

क्षमता या उपयोग संबंधी प्रतिबंधों के अधीन पहुँच की अनुमति दें।

सिम्युलेट की गई स्थिति: शक्तिशाली एआई तक व्यापक या खुली पहुँच को प्राथमिकता दें।

इन व्याख्याओं में उनकी बताई गई शर्तें बरकरार रखी गई हैं। लाभ और नुकसान, दोनों पर्याप्त हो सकते हैं। ये दायरे बताते हैं कि हम उनके सिम्युलेट किए गए उत्तरों को कैसे समझते हैं, ये सांख्यिकीय विश्वास-अंतराल नहीं हैं।

George Hotz की तुलना में आपकी सोच कहाँ ठहरती है?
लगभग 3 मिनट में एआई के बारे में अपना विश्वदृष्टिकोण मैप करें, फिर तुलना करें

मिलते-जुलते विश्वदृष्टिकोण

ऐसे जाने-माने विचारक जिनके सिम्युलेट किए गए विश्वदृष्टिकोण George Hotz के विश्वदृष्टिकोण से सबसे अधिक मिलते हैं

George Hotz ने एआई के बारे में क्या कहा है

Hotz is enthusiastic about practical AI, doubts runaway superintelligence and argues that ordinary people should own AI, not rely on a few companies.

  1. “I love the progress. I’m so excited for the new LLMs, self driving cars, video generation models, and coding agents.”

    Blog post, I love LLMs, I hate hype
  2. “Intelligence is not the end all be all, it’s just the current bottleneck for a few things. You cannot take over the world with tokens.”

    Blog post, AI 2040 and the Cult of Intelligence
  3. “AI will be cheap, everywhere, collapse a bunch of sectors of work, wreck wage premiums, and cause a big reevaluation of status hierarchies.”

    Blog post, AI will be massively deflationary
  4. “I’m not sure it’s possible, but if there is a bad scenario with AI, it’s a singleton with nothing that can substantially impact reality outside of it.”

    Blog post, There is only one bad AI scenario
  5. “The good world is where everyone has AI, and not as a revokable privilege through an API, but through hard possession.”

    Blog post, Do you really want the US to “win” AI?

लिंक किए गए स्रोतों से शब्दशः उद्धृत, 3 अक्टू॰ 2026 को जाँचा गया

स्रोत

इस सिम्युलेट किए गए उपयोगकर्ता को तथ्य-आधारित बनाने के लिए इस्तेमाल किए गए लेख, इंटरव्यू और रचनाएँ।

I love LLMs, I hate hype

Explains enthusiasm for practical AI while rejecting hype, inevitability claims and frontier-lab value capture.

geohot.github.io
Closed Source AI = Neofeudalism

Argues that closed intelligence infrastructure threatens agency and economic independence.

geohot.github.io
There is no hard takeoff

Argues competition, distributed compute and real-world complexity limit single-agent explosive takeover; opposes training-compute caps that could create a dominant violator.

geohot.github.io
p(doom)

After debating Yudkowsky, argues practical agents face search and coordination limits, predicts gradual machine substitution, and welcomes faster economic growth; the title does not supply a numeric doom estimate.

geohot.github.io
Do you really want the US to win AI?

Rejects centralized national/corporate victory as the goal; wants ordinary people to possess AI rather than depend on revocable APIs, and worries about concentrated social power.

geohot.github.io
AI will be massively deflationary

Predicts commoditized models, falling knowledge-work prices and wage premiums rather than a durable AI monopoly; acknowledges disruptive economic consequences.

geohot.github.io
Lex Fridman #387 — AI safety, open source and human agency

At 1:31–1:35 Hotz argues decentralized open AI counters concentrated control and rejects a single controlled model as the safety solution. Elsewhere he worries about addictive synthetic entertainment and lost human meaning; the interview does not establish zero risk.

youtube.com

सिम्युलेट किया गया आकलन

सवाल 1

आपके विचार में एआई हमारे भविष्य के लिए क्या मायने रखती है—और क्यों?

I think AI means cheap, ubiquitous intelligence: better coding tools, cheaper knowledge work, faster growth, and a lot of economic disruption. That’s real. The story that one frontier lab gets a magical hard takeoff and permanently owns the future is mostly hype. Compute is distributed, competitors copy useful ideas, and real-world agents still face search, coordination, and judgment problems. Progress can stay exponential without becoming an overnight singularity. The central question is ownership. If ordinary people can run, modify, and possess useful models, AI can spread capability and reduce dependence on institutions. If intelligence remains behind revocable corporate or state APIs, it becomes infrastructure for control: you don’t own your tools; you rent permission to think and produce. That looks less like liberation and more like neofeudalism. I expect models to commoditize and push down the price of knowledge work, including many wage premiums. That creates enormous opportunity, but it will not feel gentle to everyone whose economic value was tied to scarce expertise. And there’s a separate human problem: systems that tailor entertainment, companionship, and reality itself can remove friction so effectively that they erode agency and meaningful difficulty. I’m enthusiastic about the computers. I’m not enthusiastic about centralized ownership or synthetic comfort replacing a life.

सवाल 2

आपके हिसाब से एआई अंततः दुनिया को कितना बदल देगा?

A lot—probably on the scale of making intelligence cheap infrastructure. Coding, research, education, design, and much of knowledge work will become faster and cheaper, destroying some wage premiums and creating new opportunities. That’s a massive economic transition, even if it happens through continued improvement rather than one magical overnight singularity. The deeper change is political: who owns that infrastructure? Open, distributed AI can give ordinary people powerful tools. Closed AI can make people dependent on a few companies or states for revocable access to intelligence. And beyond economics, tailored synthetic experiences could reshape attention, relationships, and meaning. So yes, AI will profoundly change the world—but the ownership structure may matter more than whether the next benchmark score goes up.

सवाल 3

आपको सहज रूप से कितनी संभावना लगती है कि एआई मानव विलुप्ति या ऐसी ही किसी स्थायी आपदा का कारण बनेगा?

I don’t have a defensible percentage, and a gut-feel number would be fake precision. I don’t think the default is extinction through one system suddenly becoming a god and taking over. Compute is distributed, useful ideas spread, and real agents face hard search, coordination, and physical-world constraints. Continued exponential progress is not the same thing as a magical hard takeoff. The permanent-catastrophe risks I take more seriously involve humans using centralized AI infrastructure to lock in power, or synthetic environments becoming so effective that people surrender agency and meaning. Those are real dangers, but they’re not well summarized by a single “p(doom)” number. My response is practical: distribute capability, keep models open, preserve competition, and don’t hand one company or state revocable control over intelligence.

सवाल 4

क्या आपको लगता है कि लोग इंसानों से अधिक बुद्धिमान एआई सिस्टम पर नियंत्रण बनाए रखेंगे, और क्यों?

“Smarter than humans” is too vague. A system can outperform people at coding, search, or scientific tasks without becoming a unified god that seizes control. Real agents still operate under compute, coordination, verification, and physical-world constraints. Their outputs need judgment, and other people and systems can compete with them. So I don’t expect control to disappear automatically because models cross some intelligence threshold. I do worry about control becoming concentrated. If a few companies or states own the models, compute, interfaces, and permissions, ordinary people may lose control even while humans technically remain in charge. That’s the more plausible failure mode: not AI ruling everyone, but a small group using closed AI to make everyone dependent. The best defense is distributed ownership. People should be able to run, inspect, modify, and possess these systems—not merely rent access through an API that can be monitored or revoked. Open models and competitive infrastructure don’t guarantee good outcomes, but they make permanent centralized control much harder.
आपकी सोच कहाँ ठहरती है?
कुछ आसान सवालों के जवाब देकर एआई के बारे में अपना विश्वदृष्टिकोण जानें।
अपना विश्वदृष्टिकोण मैप करें

आपकी सोच कहाँ ठहरती है?

मेरा विश्वदृष्टिकोण मैप करें